Governor Jack Markell gave the State of the State speech today before a joint session of the Delaware House and Senate. The Senate chamber and balcony were packed to hear the speech that sets policy direction for the coming year.
Educators, state workers, and troopers all received praise. This might come as a surprise to the News Journal which has seemed to be hoping for, if not actually attempting to provoke, a fight between the public employee unions and the Governor.
The Governor stated his concerns with escalating health and pension costs and then added: "So the proper course is to work together with our state and public education employees to find the best and fairest ways to achieve near and long-term savings."
"We have begun a dialogue with representatives of the major state and public education union leaderships and leaders from within the General Assembly. I am open to any and all good ideas. But we must secure the necessary savings during this session of the General Assembly , because the cost of delay is just unacceptable."
This section of the speech refers to the fact that representatives from DSEA, AFSCME, and DSTA (troopers) will be meeting with members of the Governor's staff, the Office of Management and Budget, and with a few members of the General Assembly to examine health and pension issues. The model for problem solving is similar to that used several years ago to bring down costs associated with Workers Compensation in Delaware.
While public employees continue to have challenging times, there were indications in the State of the State, that the bad economy will cause hardship for others as well. Medicaid, the source of health care for the poor, seems almost certainly slated for cuts. Additionally, Grant-in-Aid which refers to a whole category of funding for charitable and service organizations may continue to see dwindling funds.
Next Thursday, January 27th, the Governor will release his recommended budget and we will get details around the direction set today.
Thursday, January 20, 2011
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
They're Off and Running.
The 146th General Assembly of Delaware convened today. As is tradition, many legislators brought family and friends to watch them take the oath of office. Today, everyone kept a watchful eye on weather, keeping ceremonies and receptions brief with a pending snow storm coming up from the south.
The new committee lists are out. The Senate Education Committee is:
David P. Sokola Chair
George H. Bunting Catherine L. Cloutier Bethany A. Hall-Long Margaret Rose Henry Michael S. Katz Liane M. Sorenson
The House Education Committee is:
Teresa Schooley Chair
Darryl Scott Vice Chair
Michael A. Barbieri Donald A. Blakey Stephanie T. Bolden Ruth Briggs King Debra J. Heffernan Earl G. Jaques S. Quinton Johnson Harvey R. Kenton John A. Kowalko Nick T. Manolakos Joseph E. Miro Edward S. Osienski
Welcome to all the new legislators. Let's all keep in mind, it's a marathon, not a sprint. July 1st is a long way away.
The new committee lists are out. The Senate Education Committee is:
David P. Sokola Chair
George H. Bunting Catherine L. Cloutier Bethany A. Hall-Long Margaret Rose Henry Michael S. Katz Liane M. Sorenson
The House Education Committee is:
Teresa Schooley Chair
Darryl Scott Vice Chair
Michael A. Barbieri Donald A. Blakey Stephanie T. Bolden Ruth Briggs King Debra J. Heffernan Earl G. Jaques S. Quinton Johnson Harvey R. Kenton John A. Kowalko Nick T. Manolakos Joseph E. Miro Edward S. Osienski
Welcome to all the new legislators. Let's all keep in mind, it's a marathon, not a sprint. July 1st is a long way away.
Wednesday, January 5, 2011
Some Opinions Better Not Shared
Delaware's News Journal Opinion Page got it wrong again. Today's spread of love came from a piece called "Calif. governor offers lesson to Delaware, D.C. politicians". What follows is a confusing piece that somehow tries to tie Governor Brown to the News Journal's own anti-union, anti-tax agenda.
The start of the NJ article puts some blame for California's mess on the movement against property taxes. However, in NJ form it quickly moves on to blame Brown's support for collective bargaining, powerful teacher unions, and income taxes. The News Journal implies that Brown will now correct these "mistakes" in his second chance as Governor of California.
Before going any further we should point out that Brown has not renounced unions. This is a NJ fantasy. Brown has been pro-worker rights throughout his career including his recent tenure as California Attorney General.
While waxing philosophical on California's economic woes, the NJ might stop and consider that 48 of 50 states are in bad economic shape right now. It's called a severe recession. States are driven to bankruptcies in recessions because revenues drop due to mass job loss and falling business profits; at the same time the need for services such as unemployment insurance and health care rises because of the same job loss. How can anyone have a serious conversation about the economic condition of any state without first acknowledging that the PRIMARY cause of their problem is the current recession? It is a revenue problem, not a spending problem.
Public employee unions, including those in California have given workers rights and FAIR pay and benefits. The emphasis is on "fair" because in spite of irresponsible reporting, public employees are not over-paid and they have health care and pensions, but those are not "Cadillac" or "extravagant" or any other exaggeration. State workers start at around $17,000 a year. If one is lucky and sticks around for 30 years, then they might make as much a first year junior executive.
Income taxes that ask more of those who have greatly benefited from society do not cause mass migrations of the affluent or businesses as suggested in the NJ opinion. There is absolutely no data that shows the wealthy fleeing any state if they are asked to pay 1% more tax on the top bracket. This is myth and it is harmful myth.
Shame on the NJ for once again slamming working people.
The start of the NJ article puts some blame for California's mess on the movement against property taxes. However, in NJ form it quickly moves on to blame Brown's support for collective bargaining, powerful teacher unions, and income taxes. The News Journal implies that Brown will now correct these "mistakes" in his second chance as Governor of California.
Before going any further we should point out that Brown has not renounced unions. This is a NJ fantasy. Brown has been pro-worker rights throughout his career including his recent tenure as California Attorney General.
While waxing philosophical on California's economic woes, the NJ might stop and consider that 48 of 50 states are in bad economic shape right now. It's called a severe recession. States are driven to bankruptcies in recessions because revenues drop due to mass job loss and falling business profits; at the same time the need for services such as unemployment insurance and health care rises because of the same job loss. How can anyone have a serious conversation about the economic condition of any state without first acknowledging that the PRIMARY cause of their problem is the current recession? It is a revenue problem, not a spending problem.
Public employee unions, including those in California have given workers rights and FAIR pay and benefits. The emphasis is on "fair" because in spite of irresponsible reporting, public employees are not over-paid and they have health care and pensions, but those are not "Cadillac" or "extravagant" or any other exaggeration. State workers start at around $17,000 a year. If one is lucky and sticks around for 30 years, then they might make as much a first year junior executive.
Income taxes that ask more of those who have greatly benefited from society do not cause mass migrations of the affluent or businesses as suggested in the NJ opinion. There is absolutely no data that shows the wealthy fleeing any state if they are asked to pay 1% more tax on the top bracket. This is myth and it is harmful myth.
Shame on the NJ for once again slamming working people.
Tuesday, January 4, 2011
Flowers Is New Treasurer
In an impressive ceremony this morning, Chip Flowers became Delaware's new State Treasurer, and the first African American to be elected to a statewide office in the First State.
Flowers chose the Delaware Museum of Art in Wilmington as the location for friends to witness him taking the oath of office. Special guests of this event included Governor Markell, Lt. Governor Denn, US Senators Carper and Coons, Congressman John Carney, Speaker Bob Gilligan of the Delaware House, Senator Blevins, Senator McDowell, Representatives Swartzkopf, Scott, Johnson, and Jaques.
Senator Carper and Governor Markell who were speakers on the program, were both former Delaware Treasurers.
Treasurer Flowers is a very bright and energetic young man who wants to do a lot with the Treasurer's position. He is an economic progressive who has interesting ideas. Unfortunately, he may face difficulties getting the resources he needs to run programs. Delaware, along with the rest of the nation, will enter the third straight year of budget deficits as revenues remain low. Tomorrow is a lot of work for Flowers, but today should be savored.
Flowers chose the Delaware Museum of Art in Wilmington as the location for friends to witness him taking the oath of office. Special guests of this event included Governor Markell, Lt. Governor Denn, US Senators Carper and Coons, Congressman John Carney, Speaker Bob Gilligan of the Delaware House, Senator Blevins, Senator McDowell, Representatives Swartzkopf, Scott, Johnson, and Jaques.
Senator Carper and Governor Markell who were speakers on the program, were both former Delaware Treasurers.
Treasurer Flowers is a very bright and energetic young man who wants to do a lot with the Treasurer's position. He is an economic progressive who has interesting ideas. Unfortunately, he may face difficulties getting the resources he needs to run programs. Delaware, along with the rest of the nation, will enter the third straight year of budget deficits as revenues remain low. Tomorrow is a lot of work for Flowers, but today should be savored.
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
DeLuca is Pro-Tem
The Delaware Senate went into special session today in order to approve a judicial appointment. In ordinary times this would be a non-event. However, in keeping with the extraordinary times in which we are living, even this day had drama.
The drama swirled around the need for the Senate to "organize" themselves. That is, before doing business they needed to pass rules and elect leadership. If not for the special session leadership would have been elected when the legislature returns January 11th, 2011. The early return forced a battle that has been brewing for weeks.
Senator Katz and Senator Peterson have been attempting to lead a revolt against incumbent President Pro-Tem, Senator DeLuca. Both made impassioned pleas to their colleagues on the floor of senate to vote against DeLuca.
However, their effort fell far short of a revolution.
Voting for DeLuca: Blevins, Bonini, Bushweller, DeLuca, Ennis, Hall-Long, Henry, Marshall, McBride, McDowell, Venables
Voting against DeLuca: Katz, Peterson, Sorenson, Simpson, Lawson
Present but not voting: Booth, Bunting, Connor, Sokola
Absent: Cloutier
DeLuca remains Pro-Tem with 11 favorable votes, 5 against his leadership, 4 not voting, and 1 absent.
The drama swirled around the need for the Senate to "organize" themselves. That is, before doing business they needed to pass rules and elect leadership. If not for the special session leadership would have been elected when the legislature returns January 11th, 2011. The early return forced a battle that has been brewing for weeks.
Senator Katz and Senator Peterson have been attempting to lead a revolt against incumbent President Pro-Tem, Senator DeLuca. Both made impassioned pleas to their colleagues on the floor of senate to vote against DeLuca.
However, their effort fell far short of a revolution.
Voting for DeLuca: Blevins, Bonini, Bushweller, DeLuca, Ennis, Hall-Long, Henry, Marshall, McBride, McDowell, Venables
Voting against DeLuca: Katz, Peterson, Sorenson, Simpson, Lawson
Present but not voting: Booth, Bunting, Connor, Sokola
Absent: Cloutier
DeLuca remains Pro-Tem with 11 favorable votes, 5 against his leadership, 4 not voting, and 1 absent.
Monday, December 13, 2010
Not Helpful
Delaware's "News Journal " featured the glaring Opinion page headline: "Student test results should be a call to arms". The headline and short piece refers to the results of the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA). PISA tests are administered to 15-year-old students in 65 nations and/or education systems (for example, China might receive a ranking, but in their case only Shanghai participated).
President Obama said the results should create a "Sputnik moment" for the country. Chester Finn a top ranking education official in the Reagan Administration added "Pearl Harbor" to the list of comparable national catastrophes.
When ranked by nation the US was 25 out of 34 in mathematics, 17th out of 34 in science and 14th in reading.
If there was a ranking of hyperbolic reaction, the US would have ranked last, with analogies and statements at the Junior High School level.
If we were a thoughtful, introspective nation we would take a deep breath and pause, before doing ANYTHING, before making ANY statements. If we are going to continue to place a great deal of importance on test scores, then the number one lesson we should take away from PISA is that what we are doing is not working. However, it seems that many decision makers will take PISA as the signal to run even faster down the wrong road.
Consider a few facts around the PISA high performer, Finland. Finland does very little testing of students. In fact, the only mandatory Finnish test is at the end of high school, before admission to college. Finland's student population of 7 to 14- year-olds receives far LESS instructional time than other countries. Also, Finland's teachers are almost all unionized.
Consider also that the PISA results were a part of a report that analyzed education systems and had some interesting, but unreported findings: Students from low socio-economic backgrounds (ie poor) will usually score a full grade level behind students from more affluent backgrounds. Private schools do no better than public schools once family economic status is factored in. School systems that must compete with charters and vouchers for students show no advantage in scoring. Schools that have grade promotion requirements (repeat the grade until you score out) actually score lower. Systems in which student tracking and grouping is allowed have lower test scores and higher achievement gaps.
I have thrown a lot of rambling facts around in this post. Let me try to knit them together in some kind of conclusion.
The News Journal and other purveyors of sensational doom about our educational system are not helping matters. In truth, they are contributing to the problem by creating a sense of panic in policy makers. Panic will lead to more of the same, faster: More testing, more high stakes for students and teachers, more class time, more teacher work time, more data, more, more, more.
Again, we need to take a deep breath and start thinking outside of our own box. And we should consider the old axiom of working smarter, not harder.
President Obama said the results should create a "Sputnik moment" for the country. Chester Finn a top ranking education official in the Reagan Administration added "Pearl Harbor" to the list of comparable national catastrophes.
When ranked by nation the US was 25 out of 34 in mathematics, 17th out of 34 in science and 14th in reading.
If there was a ranking of hyperbolic reaction, the US would have ranked last, with analogies and statements at the Junior High School level.
If we were a thoughtful, introspective nation we would take a deep breath and pause, before doing ANYTHING, before making ANY statements. If we are going to continue to place a great deal of importance on test scores, then the number one lesson we should take away from PISA is that what we are doing is not working. However, it seems that many decision makers will take PISA as the signal to run even faster down the wrong road.
Consider a few facts around the PISA high performer, Finland. Finland does very little testing of students. In fact, the only mandatory Finnish test is at the end of high school, before admission to college. Finland's student population of 7 to 14- year-olds receives far LESS instructional time than other countries. Also, Finland's teachers are almost all unionized.
Consider also that the PISA results were a part of a report that analyzed education systems and had some interesting, but unreported findings: Students from low socio-economic backgrounds (ie poor) will usually score a full grade level behind students from more affluent backgrounds. Private schools do no better than public schools once family economic status is factored in. School systems that must compete with charters and vouchers for students show no advantage in scoring. Schools that have grade promotion requirements (repeat the grade until you score out) actually score lower. Systems in which student tracking and grouping is allowed have lower test scores and higher achievement gaps.
I have thrown a lot of rambling facts around in this post. Let me try to knit them together in some kind of conclusion.
The News Journal and other purveyors of sensational doom about our educational system are not helping matters. In truth, they are contributing to the problem by creating a sense of panic in policy makers. Panic will lead to more of the same, faster: More testing, more high stakes for students and teachers, more class time, more teacher work time, more data, more, more, more.
Again, we need to take a deep breath and start thinking outside of our own box. And we should consider the old axiom of working smarter, not harder.
Monday, December 6, 2010
Newark Education Forum
Tonight, the Greater Newark Network, which usually discusses economic development, hosted a forum on education. While several of the discussion questions were from a business perspective and at least one suggested charter schools as a solution, the format was fair and open to opinions. The moderators did a good job of maintaining neutrality.
The program belonged to the audience which was divided up into small groups to discuss five questions for 15 minutes each. With each question people changed tables so that one discussed each question with a different group of people. Comments were recorded to be placed in a report.
There were two charter school supporters in the room who were zealots. I do not use the word lightly. They reminded me of new converts to a religion who feel like they have to spread the faith, even if at the point of a sword. One of these individuals, a teacher at a prominent charter school was adamant that all their students are chosen by lottery. Having seen the census on the two premier charter schools, I must ask how can anyone believe that by luck of the draw these schools end up with virtually no special education students or students with developmental disabilities?
Delaware must not be a litigious state; otherwise someone would surely sue one of these charters for these so called "lotteries" that miraculously always ended up with the schools getting very bright students without learning disabilities or behavioral problems.
Fortunately, the charter chant did not drown out many other good ideas in the room including using the magnet model and the school within a school model.
The program belonged to the audience which was divided up into small groups to discuss five questions for 15 minutes each. With each question people changed tables so that one discussed each question with a different group of people. Comments were recorded to be placed in a report.
There were two charter school supporters in the room who were zealots. I do not use the word lightly. They reminded me of new converts to a religion who feel like they have to spread the faith, even if at the point of a sword. One of these individuals, a teacher at a prominent charter school was adamant that all their students are chosen by lottery. Having seen the census on the two premier charter schools, I must ask how can anyone believe that by luck of the draw these schools end up with virtually no special education students or students with developmental disabilities?
Delaware must not be a litigious state; otherwise someone would surely sue one of these charters for these so called "lotteries" that miraculously always ended up with the schools getting very bright students without learning disabilities or behavioral problems.
Fortunately, the charter chant did not drown out many other good ideas in the room including using the magnet model and the school within a school model.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)